Supply Chain Disputes: Termination, Force Majeure and Limiting Liability
Commercial supply relationships are under constant pressure. Shortages, price volatility, sanctions, logistics disruption and insolvency in the supply chain all test the contracts on which businesses depend. When one party cannot or will not perform, disputes quickly follow over who can terminate, who bears the loss and how much can be recovered.
English law gives considerable weight to freedom of contract. In supply chain disputes, the outcome usually depends on the precise wording of the contract. This article looks at the key issues that arise and how businesses can manage the risk.
Termination: Getting It Right
A party may be entitled to terminate a contract in two main ways: under an express termination right in the contract, or at common law in response to a repudiatory breach, meaning a breach of a condition or a breach that deprives the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit of the contract.
Termination is one of the highest-risk steps a business can take. If a party terminates without a valid basis, it may itself be treated as having repudiated the contract, exposing it to a damages claim.
It is important to:
- Consider the contract carefully
Express termination rights often require prior notice, a cure period or service in a particular form and at a particular address.
- remember not to affirm by accident
An innocent party that continues to perform, or demands performance, after learning of a repudiatory breach may lose its right to terminate for that breach.
Force Majeure and Frustration
‘Force majeure’ is a term that broadly means an unforeseeable event outside anyone’s control, such as a natural disaster, pandemic, war or sudden government action. Many businesses assume that if something like this happens, they are automatically let off their contractual obligations. Under English law, that is not the case:
- It depends on your contract.
English law has no general rule excusing performance because of unforeseen events. You can only rely on force majeure if your contract contains a force majeure clause, and what it covers depends entirely on its wording.
- The event must be covered.
Clauses usually list the events that count. If the problem you face is not on the list, or does not fit the general description, the clause may not help you.
- You must show the event actually caused the problem.
It is usually not enough that performance has become more expensive or inconvenient. You will normally need to show that the event prevented, hindered or delayed you from performing.
- You must try to limit the damage.
Most clauses require you to take reasonable steps to work around the problem.
- Deadlines matter.
Many clauses require you to notify the other side quickly, sometimes in a specific form. Missing a notice deadline can mean losing protection altogether.
Where there is no applicable clause, a party may argue that the contract has been frustrated. Frustration applies only where a supervening event makes performance impossible, or radically different from what the parties contemplated. The threshold is very high. Increased cost or difficulty is rarely enough.
Limitation and Exclusion Clauses
Most supply contracts include clauses that limit how much one business can claim from the other if something goes wrong. These are often buried in the small print, but they can make a dramatic difference to the outcome of a dispute. In some cases, they mean a business can recover only a fraction of its actual losses.
Questions to consider:
- Is there a cap on the claim?
Many contracts set a maximum amount that can be claimed.
- Are certain types of loss ruled out altogether?
Contracts often exclude indirect/consequential loss, i.e. losses that do not flow naturally from the breach, such as unusual knock-on effects the other side could not reasonably have foreseen.
- Is lost profit covered?
Whether you can recover profit loss depends on how the contract is drafted. Some contracts expressly exclude lost profits; others do not.
Even where a clause appears to limit your claim, it may not be the final word. Where a business has contracted on the other party’s standard terms, the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 can require the clause to be fair and reasonable before it can be relied on.
Practical Steps
When disruption strikes, businesses should:
- Review the contract immediately, including notice, force majeure, termination, limitation and dispute resolution clauses.
- Serve notices promptly and in the correct form.
- Keep a clear record of the disruption and the mitigation steps taken.
- Communicate carefully as correspondence may later be relied on to show affirmation, waiver or repudiation.
- Consider commercial solutions, such as variation or standstill agreements, which may preserve the relationship.
Need Advice?
At Wellers, we advise individuals, organisations and businesses on numerous aspects of dispute resolution. Should you require assistance, please contact Jigna Varsani at Jigna.varsani@wellerslawgroup.com or on 020 7481 2422, or another member of the Dispute Resolution team for a no-obligation initial discussion.
Please note: This article was correct at the time of writing. The law may have since changed, which could affect the information and advice provided.
